Meta on Trial: Billion-Dollar Copyright Clash Over AI Training

Meta's latest legal battle could redefine AI copyright laws—and cost the company billions. A federal judge has ruled that a lawsuit against the tech giant can proceed, forcing Meta to answer for how it trained its AI models.


The case, originally filed in 2023 by a group of authors—including comedian Sarah Silverman—claims that Meta and OpenAI used copyrighted works without permission to train their AI systems. Even more damning, the lawsuit alleges that both companies stripped copyright information from the original texts to cover their tracks. The evidence? AI-generated outputs that closely mimic the authors' work.

Meta has been scrambling to shut down the case, but internal communications suggest that CEO Mark Zuckerberg personally approved the use of "likely pirated" materials. The move was reportedly part of a rush to develop better AI models in response to OpenAI's rapid progress. That revelation could make things much worse for Meta, as it suggests intentional copyright infringement rather than an oversight.

Judge Vince Chhabria ruled that the authors had a solid case, stating that copyright infringement constitutes a "concrete injury" and that there's sufficient evidence to suggest Meta deliberately removed copyright management information. However, he dismissed separate claims related to California fraud laws.

The stakes? Massive. If Meta loses, it could face billions in penalties and additional lawsuits from other creators whose work may have been used without consent. More importantly, the case could establish a legal framework for how AI companies handle copyrighted material. If Meta is found guilty, it could force tech giants to rethink how they train AI models—especially when it comes to scraping data from the Internet.

With the trial moving forward, Zuckerberg might have to take the stand, making this one of the most high-profile AI-related legal battles to date. The outcome could reshape the future of AI development, intellectual property law, and how companies handle data.

Want to read this in Spanish? Spanish Version >>